Showing posts with label blogging about Haitian adoption. Show all posts
Showing posts with label blogging about Haitian adoption. Show all posts

Thursday, December 2, 2010

Guatemala, Russia and Haiti Adoption Updates

UN finds irregularities in Guatemalan adoptions



The Associated Press
Wednesday, December 1, 2010; 10:46 PM 
 
GUATEMALA CITY -- A United Nations anti-corruption commission has found irregularities in Guatemala's adoption program despite government efforts to prevent fraudulent adoptions.

The International Commission Against Impunity in Guatemala says in a report it found cases where Guatemalan children were given to foreigners who were listed as their "foster parents" to circumvent a ban on international adoptions.

The commission didn't say how many such cases occurred among the 393 children adopted since 2008, when Guatemala enacted a more stringent adoption law.

Authorities suspended adoptions in 2007 after discovering evidence some babies had been stolen or had fake birth certificates. With the new law, the ban on foreign adoptions was lifted in June.

-----

Russian, U.S. Officials to Meet on Adoption Rules Following Return of Boy

Russian and U.S. officials will meet next week in Washington to complete talks on more stringent adoption regulations with a view to signing a treaty in the “near future,” State Department spokesman Philip J. Crowley said.

“We expect the process will be concluded” on Dec. 8, though “the formal agreement will not be signed,” Crowley told reporters. Officials will be “reviewing the final text so there can be a signing in the near future.”

The last round of discussions on adding safeguards to the adoption process was triggered by the case in June of a 7-year- old boy who was sent back alone to Moscow by his adoptive American mother. President Dmitry Medvedev called it a “monstrous” act and said adoptions could be banned.

Adoptions from Russia accounted for more than 10 percent of the U.S. total of 12,753 children adopted from other countries in 2009, according to statistics supplied by the State Department.

-------
Adoption allowed for kids who survived Haiti quake

After months of uncertainty, the way has been cleared for U.S. families to adopt 12 Haitian children who've been living at a Roman Catholic institution near Pittsburgh since a chaotic airlift that followed the devastating earthquake in January.


The Haitian government had sent a letter formally approving the adoptions, State Department spokeswoman Rosemary Macray said Wednesday, and the children will be matched with U.S. families over the coming weeks.

Unlike some 1,100 other children flown out of Haiti to the U.S. after the quake, the children at the Holy Family Institute in Emsworth, Pa., were not part of the adoption process prior to the disaster and, according to some legal experts, shouldn't have been eligible for the emergency program. Most of them had birth parents still living.

However, Macray said those parents, who were interviewed by U.S. officials, have formally relinquished custody.

Since their arrival in Pittsburgh on Jan. 19, the children - ranging in age from almost 2 to 13 - have been staying at the Holy Family Institute.

Preliminary steps were taken to match the children with adoptive families, and those matches will be reviewed to ensure their viability, said the institute's president, Sister Linda Yankoski. She said the four pairs of siblings among the 12 children would be kept together.

Yankoski said the prospective adoptive families are far-flung - from Oregon, Colorado and Illinois, for example. They are not being identified at this stage, and she said it's possible some of the matches could be changed.

"We have to come up with a thoughtful transition plan for these children," she said, noting that some of the children didn't understand the concept of adoption and had grown used to living with each other.

"We're going to go at the pace of the child," she said. "We're going to follow their cues."

Initially, the Haitian children were kept largely apart from the American children at Holy Family, but this fall the older ones attended public school.

Other highlights of their stay were their first experiences with hot showers and with snow.
"No one had to teach them to make a snowball and throw it - that came naturally," Yankoski said.
She said the children had spoken by phone with their families in Haiti and were expected to remain in contact with them after their adoptions.

"It's been a privilege to be of service to these children," Yankoski said. "We're thrilled that we will be able work with them through this step to having a family they can call their own."

The children were part of an airlift of 54 youths from the Bresma orphanage in Haiti's capital, Port-au-Prince, where two Pittsburgh-area sisters, Jamie and Alison McMutrie, had been volunteering for years. The sisters' urgent post-quake pleas for help were heeded - participants in the Jan. 19 airlift included Pennsylvania Gov. Ed Rendell.

-----

Klobuchar international adoption bill signed

A bill championed by U.S. Sen. Amy Klobuchar of Minnesota allowing American parents to adopt foreign sibling has been signed into law.

“Parents from Minnesota and across the nation don’t have to worry any more about splitting up families when adopting internationally,” Klobuchar said. “They also don’t have to risk exposing their adoptive children to unsafe immunizations in foreign countries. A child’s health and family stability are critical to ensuring successful adoptions, and this new law will allow families to keep their adopted children together, healthy and safe.”

Existing law make children 16 and older ineligible for international adoption, which can split up brothers and sisters.

Minnesota leads the country in international adoption rates.

Thursday, February 4, 2010

Charged With Kidnapping

The ten Baptist missionary Americans who were detained last week while trying to take 33 Haitian children out of the country were charged today with children and criminal association, a government official said.
Information Minister Marie Laurence Lassegue's announcement came shortly after the five men and five women left a hearing at the prosecutor's office without divulging what had transpired.

"Clearly there are questions about procedure as to whether they had the appropriate paperwork to move the children," according to P.J. Crowley, a spokesman for the U.S. State Department,

The U.S. is reportedly leaving it up to Haiti to the dismay of the ten defendents who went to court with suitcases packed beleiving they'd be going home.

Meanwhile, CBS News reports there are serious questions about Laura Silsby's motives. The 40-year-old business woman, founder and CEO of PersonalShopper.com, who convinced members of Idaho's Central Valley Baptist Church to follow her dream of an orphanage in Haiti, has a troubling financial history.

She's been the subject of eight civil lawsuits, 14 for unpaid wages, Whitaker reports. Her Meridian, Idaho house is in foreclosure. She's had at least nine traffic citations in the last 12 years including four for failing to register or insure her car. 
She can now add kidnapping to her resume.

This woman is “Executive Director and Founder” of “New Life Children Refuge,” a brand-new nonprofit organization which filed its incorporation papers with the state of Idaho just two months ago.  

Her church allegedly stands by her.

Wednesday, February 3, 2010

Haiti Adoption Pro and Con

The New York Times Opinion Forum presents the views of David Smolin, child trafficking expert against Prof Elizabeth Bartholet, pro-adoption attorney, E.J. Graff, Dr. Jane Aronson, Cynthia Mabry, Diane Kunz, Center for Adoption Policy, Darron Smith U of Utah.

Smolin: "Adoption trafficking has continued because the adoption community has chosen to minimize the problems, rather than fix the system. Since you can’t fix what you will not admit is broken, there is a perverse tendency to repeat, over and over again, the same mistakes in intercountry adoption."

Bartholet: "For most unparented children — children with no prospect of living with birth parents — the best option by far is early placement in adoption, and for children in poor countries adoptive homes will generally exist only internationally....it is hypocritical to delay or shut down such adoption in the name of protecting children. The real risk of abuses occurs when unparented children are not placed for adoption. "


Mabry: "...the Haitian government should declare a moratorium on adoptions until it can ascertain which of the children actually are orphaned."

Graff: "Part of what’s misleading are the words “orphan” and “orphanage.” After the Aceh tsunami, Save the Children reports, 97.5 percent of “tsunami orphans” were placed in “orphanages” — child-caring institutions — by their families so they could get an education. They didn’t need new families; their living families needed micropayments to fund school fees, books, and uniforms."

Aronson: "any rush to expedite adoptions not already in process and without the appropriate papers in place could potentially lead to child trafficking, kidnapping (even inadvertently) and abuse.
Adoption is not necessarily the best road to take. First, we must remember that families have been separated, but not destroyed. Even if a child’s parents were killed in the quake, close relatives are often eager to find and take responsibility for the child."

Smith, co-editor of “Black and Mormon”: "My research has found that black and biracial children often struggle with their cultural identity growing up in a white-dominated context. But in most cases, children of color are not taught how to deal with issues of race and conflict that they are may encounter when raised in white communities."

Monday, January 25, 2010

Soledad O'Brien's Eyewitness Report on the Haitian Relief Effort and Adoption

Soledad O'Brien "The Haiti Relief Effort" Interview with Kam Williams 

By Kam Williams, Syndicated at many news outlets where you can rad the entire story. Following are intro and some excerpts:

In the wake of the Haitian earthquake, CNN's Soledad O'Brien rushed to the region to deliver the same sort of high-quality, eyewitness coverage that she has dependably broadcast in the past on location after location from such disasters area as the Indian Ocean Tsunami and Hurricane Katrina.

KW: I told my readers I'd be speaking with you, and they sent in a lot of questions.

KW: Mirah Riben, author of a couple books on adoption asks, what you think of the people rushing to adopt Haitian babies?

SO: I think anybody who is willing to adopt a child in any situation is amazing. That's really a very selfless thing to do. However, I agree with those who say that adoption should not be rushed. The adoption process in Haiti normally takes several years, and it should. It would be terrible to risk an adoption by someone who should not be adopting a child. Still, what I find frustrating is that so many people see it as an either/or situation. You can do an airlift for kids who are dying, feed them, and return them without adopting them out. It doesn't have to be either snatching babies out of their parents' arms or leaving them there to die. There's a middle ground in there, and what's made me really angry is how the question has been posed as one or the other. Plus, there are plenty of orphanages that don't offer kids for adoption, but just take care of kids for people who can't afford to raise them. In a way, those kids are currently the most desperate, since they're totally under the radar. You get a sense that their situation is very dire and that no one is keeping track of them. So, it sort of annoys me that there isn't a sense of urgency about trying to save them, too.

KW: Mirah also feels that people inclined to adopt on impulse ought to be encouraged instead to donate money so the kids can be raised right there by relatives and grow up in Haiti in their own culture.

SO: Yeah, the impulse to adopt is coming from a great place. I felt the same way when I encountered a truck with about 25 babies lying in the back. I wanted to grab as many as I could hold and run for the border. They had diarrhea and started puking all over me. I can't tell you how many of my personal friends have asked, "What do I have to do to help one of those babies?" Their thinking is, if they're going to die, it's worth trying to save them, no matter what's involved. That's a wonderful impulse. But I think there's a vast middle ground between adoption and doing nothing. I've spoken to bureaucrats who say, "Well, you know, we don't want to rush anything," and I've responded, "But human beings are literally dying, and it really disturbs me that you're waiting." I had parents handing me their kids. They were like, "Please take this child and educate him."

KW: This reminds me that Mirah was wondering whether you're aware of the controversy suggesting that children are being taken out of the country before their relatives can be located.

SO: Absolutely! That's not a controversy. It's a fact. You should never want to adopt children out and give them a new set of parents before you've done your due diligence to find their biological parents. What I would suggest is that instead of adopting them out, you make sure they're safe and fed. You just take care of them. We certainly have the resources to do it in Haiti, once the infrastructure is fixed.

Blogging About Haiti and Adoption

Bloggers have been busy and thoughtful. Four bloggers; 30 posts:



IT'S NOT ABOUT HAITI, DAMN IT! IT'S ABOUT ADOPTION. IT'S ABOUT US

Haiti: A Little Bit About Important People in Their Own Words

Haiti: Adoption Business Trumps Aid

Haiti: Women's Health Care: "All About Abortion;" Solar Powered Bibles in the Food Line

American Life League Says No to Condoms and Contraceptives for Haitians

Bastard Nation's Statement on Haitian Adoption and Babylifts

Operation Pierre Pan Postponed; Politicians Pander

Haiti Child Evacuation: A New Operation Pedro Pan (my keystone Haitian entry)

Haiti: Misc. Updates on Adoption and Pat Robertson


Pat Robertson and Adoptee Rights


Soledad O'Brien's Eyewitness Report on the Haitian Relief Effort and Adoption

Israeli Social Service: Take Care of Our Own Kids Before Haiti's

International Adoption: A last resort 

Child Trafficking Feared in Haiti


Getting the Word Out re Haiti


Fast-Tracking Haitian Adoptions

The Word is Getting Heard  


Children are best left with their families 


Trgedy Exploited: A Sad History Repeating Itself in Haiti
Vietnam Operation baby Lifet all over again


Foreign Adoption last resort for Haiti quake orphans: Unicef

Quebec Exercises Proper Caution; Dutch Rush in: Haitian Adoptions

Haiti Update: Follow The Money

History Unlearned Repeats...Painfully and Shamefully

Haitian Adoptions: U.S. Caves to Demands

Not the Time to Adopt Haitian Quake Victims, Experts Say

Haitian Adoption UPDATE: Donaldson, UAI, and & My Perspective

Haitian Adoption Push

Reputable Ways to Help the Children of Haiti and Their Families

 

Birth Mother, First Mother Forum

Red Tape Holds Haitian Families Together

 

 

 

 

 




RussiaToday Apr 29, 2010 on Russian Adoption Freeze

Russi Today: America television Interview 4/16/10 Regarding the Return of Artyem, 7, to Russia alone

RT: Russia-America TV Interview 3/10

Korean Birthmothers Protest to End Adoption

Motherhood, Adoption, Surrender, & Loss

Who Am I?

Bitter Winds

Adoption and Truth Video

Adoption Truth

Birthparents Never Forget